ASSUMPTION – Paradox of the Arrow (2026) | REVIEW

Using reference to ancient third-hand remnants of Zeno of Elea’s treatment of unchecked logic, arguments against the presumption which arises within pluralist rhetoric, Treviso/Bologna, Italy-based death metal quartet ASSUMPTION muse upon the eh, assumed nature of temporal and physical aspects of a proposed singular existence on this marble-carved third full-length album. Steeled by thunder cut production values but built into temple via stone heavy death/doom inspired riffcraft ‘Paradox of the Arrow‘ represents a third-stage ideal from this always carefully considered set of craftsmen who’ve managed one of their most efficient yet evocative works to date herein. Their accomplishments here should prove high watermark for the attentive death/doom metal fanatic’s search this year and beyond.

Assumption formed as a duo circa 2011 by way of guitarist/vocalist Giorgio Trombino and drummer David Lucido who’d cut their teeth in collaboration as far back as the mid-2000’s per Haemophagus and well-liked ‘old school’ death crew Morbo. The original idea was to explore extreme doom metal currents with philosophical and metaphysic themes, envisioning the psychedelic ebb of earlier Esoteric additionally informed by something like ‘Meddle‘ type drift. Their initial result bore shades of true ~90’s stuff such as Winter and Ceremonium but was reasonably compared to the death metal side of Evoken, too. The original duo realized that greater ideal within their debut LP (‘Absconditus‘, 2018) which I’d reviewed favorably at the time but with a somewhat reductive attitude. I’d been a fan of the band since discovering their demo (‘Mosaic of the Distant Dominion‘, 2012) and didn’t immediately appreciate their emboldened departure from a pure death metal driven experience. From there the band would expand into a quartet and graduate from a studio-based project around ~2021, adding folks from Siderean and Undead Creep to their ranks.

With each cycle the greater kaleidoscopic scenery of Assumption‘s work transforms in perspective, each successive release conveying a leap taken in either capability or conception. The quartet’s underworld-fired ‘Hadean Tides‘ (2022) was pretty damned underrated at the time per the ideal it’d conjured via their Mark II line-up, connecting the 70’s inspired psychedelia-tranced searching intimacy of ‘Absconditus‘ with the punishing mid-paced death/doom barrage found on ‘The Three Appearances‘ (2014) EP. By going heavier on the riff count and roaring a bit deeper into the expanse they’d managed a record fully representative of their past travels while opening several portals to future sojourn. It was a fantastic record and would end up landing at #14 on my Top 100 Albums of 2022. This’d been the major hype-fuel and psychic momentum heading into ‘Paradox of the Arrow‘, an earned expectation of strong foundations and a need to explore colliding anew.

Louder, more immediately set in space, and with great emphasis on the rhythm section’s spinal presence ‘Paradox of the Arrow‘ appears designed for empyrean eminence but with no great distance between the ear and the action, dissolving the reverbed spasming one’d typically expect from Assumption‘s style. This allows very little breathing room as the tracer-popping sink into opener/title track “Paradox of the Arrow” gives way to glottal growl and mid-paced death plod per its first three or so minute span. That first impression is gravel spitting stuff, a pounding sledge more than a chainsaw in motion, but the quartet ensure the impact’s rippling output gives way to floatier, wriggling flourish and echoing exclamation which add to its atmospheric reach. I don’t know if this sums the total effect of the album but it does signal the temperament of the band’s work in step beyond ‘Hadean Tides‘ and its Incantation-esque trundling, no less volatile-yet-heady but potentially more concise in arrange.

An awesome sound and a quality stretch of maze-like, buzzing riffcraft should be enough to engage the average death metal attuned ear and that appeal only intensifies on the steady walk through ‘Paradox of the Arrow‘ where simpler sway through “A Labyrinth in Ruin” and the most keenly representative “Tombs Upon the Sun” carry the weight of Side A. The synth intro to the latter (via Trombino) further characterizes the band’s otherwise cold architecture here, balancing the deceptively straight forward death metal rhythms of their movement with Bolt Thrower-level progressions and guitarist Matija Dolinar‘s (Siderean, Kamra) knack for both entanglement and classicism. The marbled smoothness of those first three tracks kinda fly past, not without weight but with oddly paced, thunderous resonance which’d taken a few passes to really sink into frame.

We get a shadowy, centrally foaming melodic hit up front to kick off Side B via “Southwards Our Spirits Shall Forever Drift” wherein the funeral-sped doom rock of Paradise Lost or nearby might inform some of the lines carved. By the mid-point of the song deeper twists are wrenched into their rhythms but the inherent doom/sludge informed turn of the whole piece carries us into something more like internalized melodrama, a point of refuge that sinks away slow. The big event here and the outlier moment hits pretty deep into the piece as spoken word and wriggling pull-off quickly transitions into roaring and blasting advance, a harsh hit of speed to play the moment out. Assumption‘s suggested goal to alchemize their work with death/doom metal’s sense of temporality and sense of space in wield plays out with great severity to start but their concoction begins to boil and full the air more readily as the second half warms.

“Selenite” is the piece to break the celestial gates, the most outright atmospherically charged and note-heavy set of turns taken on ‘Paradox of the Arrow‘, which then resembles an inversion of the typical death/doom metal album format where details are typically frantically charged up front and loosened by the end. The choral vocals which highlight the song are a huge standout moment for my own taste, the sort of idea a funeral death/doom metal band -could- center a whole discography around per its stoic, monastic quality. Otherwise the grand finale of “Vrykolakes” acts as the impact of Assumption‘s anchoring in funereal death/doom metal surrealism, yielding none of their composure as they end on an incredible ‘Antithesis of Light‘ level haul which bends its movements into diagonally scaling riffcraft, strumming blast and star-shot tension on the path through.

Though I could attempt to sum the greater shaping of ‘Paradox of the Arrow‘ into escalating and collapsing lines of varying weight its amorphously bent yet beguilingly straightforward stance is almost better left experienced in waves of unadulterated resonance, or, repeated listens. Enormous speaker-shaking production values help to highlight this broader rhythmic design up front but I think I was at least four or five listens into Assumption‘s latest before it’d began to see tact beyond its columnar heaviness. While its totality of motion, nuance and such, should be allowed to sink into skull outright there is something to be said for the band’s ability to generate immediacy without sacrificing pace, intricacy or doom metal informed impact. With this in mind, and skimming past the album’s amazing artwork and lyricism, the quartet’s work exceeds all expectations wherein timeless foundations are expressed in concert with bespoke exploration. A very high recommendation.


Help Support Mystification Zine’s goals with a donation:

Please consider donating directly to site costs and project funding using PayPal.

$1.00